Friday, 23 August 2019   







Never see Ash'ariyyah in the same light, ever again! Aristotle of Stageira, Philo of Alexandria, Augustine of Hippo, the Sabeans of Harraan, the Mu'tazilites of Basrah and Baghdad and the Jahmite Ash'ari Heretics of Today Claiming Orthodoxy. Read the first article, the second article, the third article, the fourth article, the fifth article.
You are here: Home Articles
Abu al-Abbas al-Qalanisi (Contemporary of Abu Hasan al-Ash'ari): Allaah is Above His Throne With His Essence (But Without Contact)
Posted by Abu.Iyaad, in Articles
Topics: Abu Al-Abbas Al-Qalanisi Al-Qalanisi Al-Uluww Al-Arsh Abu Al-Abbas Al-Qalanisi Al-Qalanisi Al-Uluww Al-Arsh

  Mail To Friend    Printer Friendly Bookmark and Share

We have mentioned in numerous articles previously that the early Ash'ari Scholars were different to the later Ash'ari Scholars who took the path of the Jahmites and the Muta'zilites. The earlier Ash'aris were influenced by Abdullah bin Saeed Ibn Kullaab (d. ~240H) and what became known as the Ash'arite creed (in the earlier period) was in fact the creed of Ibn Kullaab who tried to tread a middle path between the Mu'tazilah and the people of Hadeeth, to whom he had an inclination.

And we also covered that the Early Ash'aris, such as al-Ash'ari himself, al-Baqillani, Ibn Mahdi at-Tabari all held Allaah to be above the Throne, with His Essence, and in addition to this affirmation, they would use additional phrases due to their kalaamist influence, such as "without contact" (meaning with the Throne) and "without confinement", "without being a body" and so on.

And the background to this is that when the Jahmites denied that Allaah was above the Throne (because "aboveness" is an incidental attribute that would render Him a body,and thus created) - and this is in light of al-Jahm bin Safwan's debates with the Indian Philosophers - then all the Muslims knew its falsehood, and their Imaams stood to revile and abuse the Jahmites who initiated this saying. However factions amongst those who affirmed Allaah to be above the Throne, and who fell into Tajseem and tashbeeh, such as the Karraamiyyah countered this innovation of the Jahmites in a manner opposed to the sound way adopted by the people of the Sunnah.

So they (the Karraamiyyah Mujassimah) said, "Allah is above the Throne and He is a jism (body)", although they qualified, "...but not like the created bodies". So they countered innovation, with another innovation. And the earlier Ash'arites who were upon the creed of Ibn Kullaab (d. ~240H) and they held that Allaah is above the Throne with His Essence and alongside that, they used additional phrases due to their kalaamist influence, along the lines of what has already preceded.

So in attempting to refute the Karraamiyyah, they countered innovation with another innovation. However, the issue is that the earlier Ash'aris affirmed Allaah to be above the Throne, despite their kalaamist additions on this matter. Therefore we have three groups of people:

  • The people of the Sunnah and the Imaams of the religion who reviled the saying of the Jahmites with the Book and the Sunnah and affirmed that Allaah is above the Throne, with His Essence, as opposed to being in every place according to the Jahmites.
  • Factions such as the Karraamiyyah who held Allaah to be above the Throne with His Essence and a jism (body), but unlike the created bodies - saying this to counter the rejection of the Jahmites.
  • The early Ash'arite Mutakallimoon who held Allaah to be above the Throne with His Essence, and saying, "He is not a jism (body)" and "without contact" and "without confinement" and the likes.

Now this poses a great problem for the later (Jahmite) Ash'aris, such as al-Ghazali (d. 505H), and ar-Razi (d. 606) and all Ash'aris today are upon the Jahmite creed propounded by the Later Ash'aris, in opposition to what the earlier Ash'aris were upon. So either the earliest, leading and founding Imaams of the Ash'arites were closer to the truth and upon guidance and the later Jahmite Ash'aris were upon falsehood, or the later Jahmite Ash'aris were upon truth and the earlier founding Ash'aris were upon falsehood.

That's a judgment that today's average misinformed Ash'ari has to make - and that's if he is even aware of such things, being in the clouds of deception that their leaders keep them in for fear that the true realities of the Ash'arite creed be revealed.

In this article we want to document the view of another prominent figure who was a contemporary of Abu Hasan al-Ash'ari and who is highly regarded by the Ash'ari Scholars and considered to be amongst their ranks.

Who is Abu al-Abbas al-Qalanisi?

Ibn Asakir in his "Tabyeen Kadhib al-Muftari" writes (p. 97):

He is Abu al-Abbas Ahmad bin Abdur-Rahman bin Khaall al-Qalanisi ar-Razi, from the contemporaries of Abul-Hasan - may Allaah have mercy upon him - but not from his students as has been said by al-Ahwazi. And he is from the group of the firmly-grounded senior scholars, and his creed is in agreement with his creed (i.e. that of Abul-Hasan al-Ash'aris) in affirmation (al-ithbaat).

And Abu Mansur Abdul-Qahir al-Bagdhadi (d. 429H) who is a prominent Imaam of the Ash'aris and whose works constitute foundational texts (especially "Usool ud-Deen"), refers to Abu al-Abbas al-Qalanisi as an "Imaam of Ahl us-Sunnah".

Here is the front cover to his book, "Usool ud-Deen" (Istanbul, 1928):

And on pages 309-310 of this book he lists the students of Abdullah bin Sa'eed Ibn Kullab (d. ~240H) - who is the actual and true author of what later became known as the Ash'arite creed - and he lists the prominent Ash'arite Theologians until his time. Here is the text:

In this text al-Bagdhadi mentions that from the students of Abdullah bin Saeed Ibn Kullaab are "al-Junayd, Shaykh of the Sufiyyah". Then after them says, came "Abul-Hasan bin Ali bin Isma'il al-Ash'ari". And then he mentions from the students of al-Ash'ari, "Abul-Hasan al-Bahili" and "Abu Abdullah bin Mujahid".

And then he mentions the leading Imaams of (the Ash'arites) of the time, "Abu Bakr Muhammad Ibn at-Teeb [al-Baqillani], the Qadi of the Qadis of Iraq".

He also mentions Abu Bakr Ibn Fawrak, Abu Ishaaq Ibrahim Ibn Muhammad al-Mihrani, Abu al-Hasan Ibn Mahdi at-Tabari and al-Hussain bin Muhammad al-Bazzaazi, and Abu 'Alee ath-Thaqafi.

And then he says:

... And in his time, the Imaam of Ahl us-Sunnah was Abu al-Abbas al-Qalanisi whose works in al-kalaam (theological speculation) numbered more than 150 books...

So now that we understand who Abu al-Abbas al-Qalanisi is, through the words of the Ash'arites themselves, we can now proceed to his viewpoint on the issue of al-istiwaa and al-uluww.

Abu al-Abbas al-Qalanisi on Allaah Being Above the Throne With His Essence

Al-Qalanisi's position is quoted by Abdul-Qahir al-Baghdadi in the same book, "Usool ud-Deen". Here are pages 112-113:

In these pages al-Baghdadi brings the heading, "The Fifteenth Issue Regarding This Foundation: On the Meaning al-istiwaa Annexed to Him [Allaah]". Then he mentions the various differences on the issue and he describes the opinions of the factions:

Then he mentions about the differences on the issue amongst themselves (i.e. referring to himself and the Ash'arite theologians):

  • Amongst them are those who say the verse of al-istiwaa is amongst the ambiguous texts (mutashaabihaat) whose interpretation is only known by Allaah. And al-Baghdadi claims that this is the view of Imaam Malik and the jurists of Madinah - and this is an erroneous claim regarding Imaam Malik, for Malik affirmed that "al-Istiwaa ma'qool (Istiwaa is understood)" and in other narrations, "al-Istiwaa ghayr majhool (Istiwaa is not unknown)" and he denied the kaifiyyah by saying "wal kayf majhool (and how is unknown)". And the kaifiyyah of something can only be negated if its meaning is known - as for when something does not have any meaning to begin with, then there is no purpose in negating a kaifiyyah for it. So this is an error in ascribing this to Imaam Maalik.

  • Then al-Baghdadi continues and mentions the view of those that al-istiwaa is an act that Allaah creates within the Throne itself which is referred to as al-istiwaa and it is not actually an action of Allaah - and says that this is the view of Abul-Hasan al-Ash'ari.

Then he mentions the last view, saying:

And amongst them are those who say that His istiwaa (ascending) over the Throne is His being above the Throne without contact (mumaassah), and this is the saying of al-Qalanisi, and Abdullah bin Sa'eed [Ibn Kullaab], he mentioned it in "Kitaab us-Sifaat".

Then after this al-Bagdhadi details what he believes to be the correct view which is that the Throne (al-Arsh) is a metaphor for Allaah's dominion (mulk) and this is a false and baseless ta'weel in light of the Book and the Sunnah and it is rejected by the likes of al-Bayhaqi - who is considered an Ash'ari - (see here) and it opposes what is held by Ahl us-Sunnah unanimously that the Throne is a true and real created entity.

Notes and Comments on the Above

To follow inshaa'Allaah.


Link to this article:   Show: HTML LinkFull LinkShort Link
Share or Bookmark this page: You will need to have an account with the selected service in order to post links or bookmark this page.

                 
  
Subscribe via RSS or email:
Follow us through RSS or email. Click the RSS icon to subscribe to our feed.

     

Related Articles:
Add a Comment
You must be registered and logged in to comment.





Don't Be Deceived By the Terminology of the Jahmiyyah!
(Introduction) (al-jism) (al-'arad) (Hulul al-hawaadith) (al-tarkib
)

Series View More...

Topics
Basics
Scholars
History
Misconceptions
Ibn Taymiyyah
Articles
Sunni Answers
Audio
The Clinic

Latest Articles
The History and Origins of the Kalam Theology of the Asharis and Maturidis
Revelation, Philosophy and Kalam: The Creed of the Salaf Versus the Creed of the Asharis and Maturidis
The Creed of the Kullabi Asharis Preview: Part 11 - Concerning the Affirmation and Negation of Al-Hadd and the Doubts of the Jahmites
The Divine Attributes: The Righteous Salaf vs the Heretical Kalam Schools - Part 2: Which Door Did the Ash'aris and Maturidis Come Through?
The Divine Attributes: The Righteous Salaf vs the Heretical Kalam Schools - Part 1: Introduction
The Saying of the Salaf (منه بدأ وإليه يعود), Imaam Al-Tahawi's Uncreated Single Qur'an and Sa'eed Foudah's Two Qur'an Doctrine: Part 3
The Saying of the Salaf (منه بدأ وإليه يعود), Imaam Al-Tahawi's Uncreated Single Qur'an and Sa'eed Foudah's Two Qur'an Doctrine: Part 2
The Saying of the Salaf (منه بدأ وإليه يعود), Imaam Al-Tahawi's Uncreated Single Qur'an and Sa'eed Foudah's Two Qur'an Doctrine: Part 1
Another Dishonest and Resentful Jahmite (Nizar Hammadi) Trying to Malign Ibn Taymiyyah: Regarding Fakhr Al-Din Al-Razi's Confusion
Deconstructing the Micro Madrasa (Of Ilm Al-Kalaam and Tajahhum) of Ibrahim Osi-Efa (Liverpool, UK): Part 4

Pages
No pages found.

Most Popular
Destroying the Slander of Tajsim (Anthropomorphism) Against Ahl al-Sunnah wal-Jamaa'ah: Part 1 - Developing The Framework
Ibn Taymiyyah Compared With the Philosophers: Exposing Abu Adam al-Naruiji's Academic Fraud - Part 5: Ahl al-Sunnah, the Philosophers and Ahl al-Kalaam on Allaah's Actions and Origins of the Universe - Continued...
Aristotle of Stageira, Philo of Alexandria, Augustine of Hippo, the Sabeans of Harraan, the Mu'tazilites of Basrah and Baghdad and the Jahmite Ash'ari Heretics of Today Claiming Orthodoxy- Part 1
Ibn Taymiyyah Compared With the Philosophers: Exposing Abu Adam al-Naruiji's Academic Fraud - Part 4: Ahl al-Sunnah, the Philosophers and Ahl al-Kalaam on Allaah's Actions and Origins of the Universe
The American Chestnut Tree, The Willow Tree, Jahm Bin Safwan, The Mu'tazilah, Ibn Kullaab and the Early and Later Ash'aris - An Illustration
Abu Hamid al-Ghazali (Imaam of the Later Ash'aris): If the Prophet Invited to Belief in Allaah Through the Language and Terminology of the Ash'arites, Not even One in a Thousand Would Accept It! Rather the Majority Would Tend to Atheism!
Destroying the Slander of Tajsim (Anthropomorphism) Against Ahl al-Sunnah wal-Jamaa'ah: Part 2 - Ahl al-Sunnah, Ibn Kullab, al-Ash'ari and the Early Kullabis, Ash'aris
Destroying the Slander of Tajsim (Anthropomorphism) Against Ahl al-Sunnah wal-Jamaa'ah: Part 3 - The Mu'attilah and Mujassimah Share the Same Base and Foundation For Their Ta'teel and Tajseem
Undercover Ash'aris: Understanding The Intellectual Fraud Needed by Today's Ash'aris To Prop Up and Defend their (Neo-Jahmite) Creed: Analysis of a Sample of Marifah Apologeticism Regarding Distinction Between the Attributes - Part 1
Why Ibn Sina, You Exceedingly Shrewd Kafir! Thank You For Supporting Our Aristotelian Metaphysical Creed and Backing Us (Ash'aris) In Our Saying That 'Allaah Is Not Within the Creation Nor Outside Of It'

Archives (View more)
2018 • January
2017 • December
2014 • December
2013 • November
2013 • October
2013 • September
2013 • August
2013 • July
2013 • June
2011 • October
2011 • September
2011 • August


Key Topics
21st century kalam atomistabdullaah ibn al-mubaarakabdullah ali al-aminabdul-qadir al-jeelaaneeabdul-qadir al-jilaniabu abdullah bin hamidabu adam al-naruijiabu adam naruijiabu adam narujiabu al-abbas al-qalanisiabu al-hasan bin al-zaghuniabu al-hudhayl al-allaafabu ali al-ahwaziabu bakr al-baqillaniabu bakr al-ismaa'eeleeabu bakr al-isma'iliabu bilal malikiabu fadl al-tamimiabu hamid al-ghazaliabu hanifahabu hasan al-ash'ariabu isma'il al-harawiabu layth bin ataaabu mansur al-baghdadiabu ya'laaabul-hasan ibn mahdi at-tabariaccidentadh-dhahabeeadh-dhahabiaf'aal ikhtiyaariyyahahl al-kalaamahl al-kalamahmad bin sinan al-waasiteeahmed cobraakhbaar ul-aahaadal-aamideeal-akhtalal-amidial-'aradal-arshal-ash'areeal-asharial-ash'arial-baqillanial-bayhaqial-bukhaareeal-dhahabial-ghazalial-haddal-hawaadithal-ibanahal-istiwaaal-jahm bin safwanal-jawhar al-fardal-jihahal-jismal-juwayneeal-juwaynial-kawthareeal-khateeb al-baghdaadeeal-khatib al-baghdadiallaah's angerallaah's namesallaah's pleasureal-milal wan-nihalal-muhasibial-naruijial-nawaweeal-nawawial-qadi abd al-wahhab al-malikial-qadi abu ya'laaal-qalanisial-qurtubeeal-qurtubial-qushayrial-razial-shahrastanial-tabyinal-taftazanial-tahawial-tarkibal-uluwwal-uluwwwal-wajhal-yadan-nadhr al-istidlaalan-nawawianthropomorphismanthropomorphistsa'raad'aradaristotelian metaphysicsaristotelians anonymousaristotlear-raziarshasaas ut-taqdisashareesash'areesash'ariash'ari burnoutashari scholarsash'ari scholarsasharisash'ariteash'aritesash'ariyyahasmaaasrar rasheedasrar rashidas-sanusiatabek shukrov nasafiatheismatomismat-tabariat-tirmidheeaugustineaydinbaqillanibarelwibayaan talbees al-jahmiyyahbayjooribayjuribelief sciencebetter ash'aribi dhatihibishr al-mareesibucket theologycompetition cornercompositeday of arafahdemocritusdetoxdivisibleearly asharisearly ash'ariseesaaencompassmentfake hanbalisfakhr al-din al-razifakhr ud-din ar-razifalaasifahfalsafahfaqirfawqiyyahforty hadithgf haddadghadabgrave worshipgreek philosophershaadithhaashiyahhanbalisharfharranhellenismhishaamiyyahhizb ut-tahrirhudoothhudooth ul-ajsaamhuloolhulul al-hawadithibn abi zayd al-qayrawaniibn al-mutahhiribn asaakiribn asakiribn battahibn darbasibn fawrakibn hajribn hajr al-asqalaniibn jareer at-tabariibn jarir al-tabariibn khuzaymahibn kullaabibn kullabibn mahdi al-tabariibn seenaibn sinaibn taymiyyahibrahim osi-efaidol worshipihaatahilm al-kalaamilm al-kalamilm ul-kalamimaam adh-dhahabiimaam ahmadimaam ahmad bin hanbalimaam ash-shaafi'eeimam malikinqisaamintercessionintoxicationistidlaalistiwaaithbaatittihaadityaanjahm bin safwaanjahm bin safwanjahmee baleedjahmeespeakjahmi baleedjahmitejahmite ash'arisjahmitesjahmiyyahjahmiyyah mu'tazilahjawharjawharahjawharat ut-tawhidjihahjismjismiyyahkalaamkalaam nafseekalaam nafsikalam atomismkalam nafsikarraamiyyahkhabar ul-waahidkullaabi ash'ariskullaabiyyahkullabi asharislafdhiyyahlater ash'arisliquormarifahmetaphysicsmicro madrasamuhammad abduhmuhammad anwar shah al-kashmirimuhammad fahmimuhammad sa'eed ramadan al-butimuhdathmujassimahmurakkabmushabbihahmutafalsifahmutakallimoonmu'tazilahnadhrnaqd al-tadmuriyyahnaruijinaseehah dhahabiyyahneo-hanbalisneo-platonismnihaayat ul-iqdaamnizar hammadinuh ha mim kellernuh kellernur uz zamaan institutenuzoolpersonal developmentphiladelphian jahmite ash'arisphiladelphian jahmitesphilophilosophersplatopseudo-hanbalisqadi abdul-jabbarquraanquranqu'ranqur'anqur'an creationistsridhaariyadh al-saaliheenrizqullah al-tamimisaalimiyyahsabeanssaeed foudahsaeed foudah sa'id foudahsaint worshipsalafiyyahsawtsayyid qutbseeking ilmself awarenessself helpshafaa'ahshahrastaanishahrastanisifaatsifaat dhaatiyyahsifaat fi'liyyahsifat fi'liyyahsifat khabariyyahsubstancesumaniyyahtabyin kadhib al-muftaritafweedtaj al-din al-subkitajseemtajsimtakaafu' al-adillahtakyeeftamtheeltaqi ad-din an-nabahanitaqiuddin al-nabhanitarkeebtashbeehta'teelta'weeltawhidtawhid al-ibaadahtawhid al-ibadahtawhid al-uloohiyyahtawhid al-uluhiyyahta'wilthe clinicthe quranthe thronetheologiansthomas aquinasthronetop tipsuluwwundercover ash'arisvoicewahhabiwahhabisyahyaa bin ammaaryusuf al-qaradawiyusuf an-nabahani
Copyright © 2019 . All rights reserved. RSSTagsPrivacyLegal and Terms of UseSitemap