Wednesday, 10 March 2010    HomeAbout UsContact Us     



The Fake Pseudo-Hanbali Movement: Part 1 - Brief Introduction
Filed under: Articles
Monday, November 16 2009 - by Asharis.Com
Key topics: Neo-Hanbalis Fake Hanbalis Pseudo-Hanbalis

Mail to a FriendPrinter friendly

The Pseudo-Hanbali movement is a devised, structured and planned attempt by the opposers of the creed and methodology of the Salaf to use the name of Imaam Ahmad, his fiqh, the Hanbali madhhab and its Scholars as a route to introduce ta'weel, ta'teel and tafweed to unsuspecting Muslims, to defend the Ash'aris and Maturidis, and to open up the door for those innovations in worship well-known with the Sufis. In short, these are Sufis, Ash'aris in reality, upon the madhhab of tafweed who have adopted the Hanbali madhhab in fiqh as a means of hijacking the Hanbali creed and diverting it to their own views, using selected, isolated statements of the Hanbali Scholars in a limited range of issues to push their overall agenda.

As this is an introductory article, we will simply provide brief and concise points which will be expanded upon in detail in other articles inshaa'Allaah.

Broad Aspects of the Fake Pseudo-Hanbalis

  • The Fake Hanbalis have been nurtured upon the creed of the Ash'ariyyah and Maturidiyyah and particularly the madhhab of tafweed which was propagated by the likes of al-Juwaynee (d. 478H) due to their non-satisfaction with ta'weel as a means to explain away those revealed texts which implied (to them) that Allaah has incidental attributes (a'raad) and events, occurrences (hawaadith) which - in accordance with their rational proof of "hudooth ul-ajsaam" for proving the universe is created and has a creator - would have rendered Allaah a body (jism), like the created bodies (ajsaam).

  • Following on from that, they utilize the Hanbali fiqh as a means to introduce such a creed to unsuspecting Muslims.

  • The Fake Hanbalis make reference to the persons and works of the likes of Nuh Keller, Abdal-Hakim Murad, and others who are Ash'arites and Ahl ul-Kalaam. And this is from the most obvious of matters that exposes these people as fakes. Association with the Hanbali fiqh is just a means to distort the creed of Imaam Ahmad which is none other than that of the Righteous Salaf. And if you want to convince people of your fake-Hanbalism, at least have the brains not to mention the likes of these people (Keller, Murad) which gives your game away from the very beginning.

  • Showing sympathy, defending, arguing for, and accommodating the Ash'arites with a view to introducing unsuspecting Muslims to their creed and arguing for its legitimacy and leaving the door open for "ta'weel" of the attributes to be considered as a legitimate methodology despite feigning to oppose it.

  • Challenging the correct, orthodox understanding of "bid'ah" with the Salaf, by making use of certain issues (in the domain of fiqh rulings) in which there are differences of opinion (amongst the Hanbalis) in order to extend justification and legitimacy by way of this to forbidden forms of worship (which clearly enter into the domain of bid'ah and shirk).

  • Arguing the case for the "Mawlid" which is celebrating the Prophet's birthday.

  • Feigning agreement with Imaam Ahmad on the issue of the Qur'an whilst in reality attempting to make excuses for the Lafdhiyyah Jahmiyyah (who are the origin and source of the saying of the As'harites of "Kalaam Nafsee" and of the createdness of the Qur'an we have with us, in letter and word) and trying to cut off and prevent any detailed speech on this matter. Detailed clarification of the truth in this matter is from the manifest hallmarks of Imaam Ahmad bin Hanbal - and this is from the greatest of what exposes these Pseudo-Hanbalis as Ash'arite Mufawwidh Mutasawwifah feigning attachment to the creed of Imaam Ahmad.

  • Feigning agreement with the Hanbalis in the issue of al-uluww whilst secretly abhorring the question "Where is Allaah?" and withholding from speaking with what the entirety of the Salaf and the early Kullaabi Ash'aris affirmed that Allaah Himself, with His Essence, is above the Throne, above the heavens, in opposition to the Jahmiyyah and Mu'tazilah. And claiming that raising this issue is only a fitnah (tribulation) and has no connection to creed!

  • Feigning agreement with the Hanbalis on the issue of al-istiwaa whilst deliberately creating confusion my mixing the sayings of the Mu'tazilah, Ash'ariyyah and their ta'weels of this attribute, with the sayings of the Hanbalis - in order to deceive unsuspecting Muslims and to mix truth with falsehood.

  • Their attachment to and concern with the books such as "Usool us-Sunnah" of Imaam Ahmad and "Lumu'at ul-I'tiqaad" of Ibn Qudaamah and others with a view to propagating the creed of tafweed ul-ma'naa (that the meanings of the attributes are not known in reality), and with a view to writing apologetics in these translations and printed works to defend and legitimize the way of the Ash'aris and Maturidis and explaining away subjects such as al-uluww, and al-istiwaa upon the way and style of the Ash'arites. So by way of example, they make use of statements in the book of Ibn Qudaamah which they think support their Ash'arite methodology of tafweed, when the reality is otherwise.

This is only a small list, there is much more, but from this alone one can clearly see that these people are in reality Ash'arite Mufawwidah Mutasawwifah using the fiqh of the Hanbali Madhhab as a veil to further the creed that they are upon, mixing much of the truth with much of falsehood, and pushing the claim that there are three legitimate schools of creed, what they call "the Hanbali Athari" school, the Ash'aris and the Maturidis. Inshaa'Allaah we shall be expanding upon these issues in specific articles, and taking some of the works, translations and polemical writings of these fake Neo-Hanbalis, and exposing what is within them of clear error and deception by Allaah's permission.



Link to this article:   Show: HTML LinkFull LinkShort Link
Related Articles:
Add a Comment (comments are currently moderated)
You must be registered and logged in to comment.


Imaam adh-Dhahabi, Ibn Taymiyyah and the 'Naseehah Dhahabiyyah' (5)
Ibn Hajr al-Asqalani and the Ash'aris (5)
Regarding Qaadee Abu Bakr al-Baqillani (9)
Atomism and Hudooth ul-Ajsaam: The Core Foundation of the Jahmite Ash'ari Religion (12)
Sunni Answers To Devious Jahmee Doubts (10)
The Creed of the Early Ash'ari Scholars Differs From the Later (Jahmite) Ash'ari Scholars (15)
Imaams of the Later Ash'aris: Our Creed Would Lead the Common Folk to Atheism (2)
Ibn Kullaab (d. 240H): The True and Real Author of the Creed of the Earlier Ash'aris (7)
The Usool of the Ash'ariyyah Are the Usool of the Mu'tazilah (2)
Ash'ari Competition and Quiz Corner - Test Your Ash'ariyyah (3)
Top Tips To Become A Better Ash'ari (2)
The Jahmite Ash'aris on the Speech of Allah, the Qur'an and Kalam Nafsee (19)
Aristotelians Anonymous - Detox and Support Program (2)
Latest Reports
The Creed of Abu Hasan al-Ash'aree in the Latter Part of His Life
Latest Articles
The Top Intellectual Frauds Perpetrated by Today's Jahmiyyah Posing as Followers of Abu al-Hasan al-Ash'ari - Part 2: Regarding Ibn Kullaab al-Qattaan al-Basri
The Ash'ari Creed and 20th Century Egyptian Thinkers and Political Activists: Part 1 - The Aqidah of Sayyid Qutb
Imaam adh-Dhahabee on Abdullaah bin Sa'eed bin Kullaab (d. 240H): The Founder of the Creed That Became Popularized Through Abu al-Hasan al-Ash'ari and the Early Ash'aris, Then Jahmified By the Later Ones
Abu Bakr al-Ismaa'eelee (d. 371H) Delisted From the Spurious Lists Of So-Called 'Ash'ari' Scholars
Imaam ash-Shaafi'ee: 'Whoever Says My Pronunciation of the Qur'an is Created is a Jahmee': Jahmiyyah Ash'ariyyah: 'Our Pronunciation of the Qur'an is Created'
Imaam Ahmad bin Hanbal (d. 241H) : Affirmation of the Attribute of Voice (Sawt) for Allaah
Abdul-Kareem Ash-Shahrastani, Sixth Century Ash'ari (d. 548H): Abu al-Hasan al-Ash'ari Broke the Ijmaa' and Innovated a Third Saying On the Subject of Allaah's Speech and the Qur'an
The Top Intellectual Frauds Perpetrated by Today's Jahmiyyah Posing as Followers of Abu al-Hasan al-Ash'ari - Part 1: Regarding the Qur'an
Abdul-Malik al-Juwaynee (d. 478H): Ibn Kullaab Is From Amongst Our Associates
Requesting Marifah Staff (And All Contemporary Jahmiyyah Posing as 'Ash'arites' in Every Corner of the World) To Announce Their Repentance For Lying Against Allaah and His Religion and For Reviling the Deen of the Early Kullaabi Ash'arites
Search This Site

Most Popular
The Philadelphian Jahmite Ash'ari Scandals Of 2009: Regarding Ibn Taymiyyah, Allaah's Nuzool and the Jahmee Invented Doubt Concerning Whether the Throne Becomes Unoccupied or Not
Regarding Ibn Taymiyyah and the 'Naseehah Dhahabiyyah' Ascribed to Imaam adh-Dhahabee - Part 1
A Historical Outline of the Deen Instituted by the Jahmites Subsequently Adopted by the Mu'tazilah, Ash'ariyyah and Maturidiyyah
Ibn Taymiyyah: Hudooth ul-Ajsaam Is The Foundation of the Deen of the Theologians (Jahmites, Mu'tazilites and Ash'arites): Part 1 - Must Read If You Want To Understand Why Negating Allaah's Attributes Entered the Ummah
Undercover Ash'aris: Understanding The Intellectual Fraud Needed by Today's Ash'aris To Prop Up and Defend their (Neo-Jahmite) Creed: Analysis of a Sample of Marifah Apologeticism Regarding Distinction Between the Attributes - Part 1
Impaling Jahmee Doubts: An Open Invitation To Nuh Keller To Recant and Repent From His Ta'weel Frauds - The Attribute of Hands
The American Chestnut Tree, The Willow Tree, Jahm Bin Safwan, The Mu'tazilah, Ibn Kullaab and the Early and Later Ash'aris - An Illustration
Aristotelians Anonymous: The Official Launch - Time For A New Beginning!
Ibn Hajr al-Asqalani's Mention of the Ash'ari Sect By Name in Fath ul-Baaree - Part 1
Regarding Ibn Taymiyyah and the 'Naseehah Dhahabiyyah' Ascribed to Imaam adh-Dhahabee - Part 2

Tags
21st century kalam atomist abdullaah ibn al-mubaarak abdul-qadir al-jeelaanee abdul-qadir al-jilani abu adam naruiji abu adam naruji abu al-abbas al-qalanisi abu al-hudhayl al-allaaf abu bakr al-baqillani abu bakr al-ismaa'eelee abu bakr al-isma'ili abu hamid al-ghazali abu hasan al-ash'ari abu isma'il al-harawi abul-hasan ibn mahdi at-tabari accident adh-dhahabee adh-dhahabi af'aal ikhtiyaariyyah ahmad bin sinan al-waasitee ahmed cobra akhbaar ul-aahaad al-arsh al-ash'aree al-ash'ari al-bayhaqi al-bukhaaree al-ghazali al-hadd al-ibanah al-istiwaa al-jahm bin safwan al-jawhar al-fard al-juwaynee al-kawtharee al-khateeb al-baghdaadee al-khatib al-baghdadi allaah's anger allaah's names allaah's pleasure al-milal wan-nihal al-qadi abu ya'laa al-qalanisi al-qurtubee al-qurtubi al-shahrastani al-taftazani al-uluww al-wajh al-yad an-nadhr al-istidlaal an-nawawi anthropomorphism anthropomorphists aqeedah aqidah a'raad 'arad aristotelian metaphysics aristotelians anonymous aristotle ar-razi arsh asaas ut-taqdis asharees ash'arees ash'ari ash'ari burnout ash'ari clinic ashari scholars ash'ari scholars asharis ash'aris of philadelphia ash'arite ash'arites ash'ariyyah asmaa as-sanusi atheism atomism at-tabari at-taftazani at-tirmidhee attributes aydin az-zilal baqillani bayaan talbees al-jahmiyyah bayjoori bayjuri belief science better ash'ari bishr al-mareesi bucket theology competition corner composite composition day of arafah democritus detox divisible early asharis early ash'aris eesaa encompassment fake hanbalis fakhr ud-din ar-razi falaasifah falsafah fawqiyyah fi zilal il-qur'an ghadab greek philosophers haashiyah harf harran hellenism hudooth hudooth ul-ajsaam hulool ibn battah ibn fawrak ibn hajr ibn hajr al-asqalani ibn jareer at-tabari ibn kullaab ibn kullab ibn seena ibn sina ibn taymiyyah ihaatah ilm ul-kalam imaam adh-dhahabi imaam ahmad imaam ash-shaafi'ee inqisaam intoxication istidlaal istiwaa ithbaat ittihaad ityaan jahm bin safwaan jahm bin safwan jahmee baleed jahmeespeak jahmi baleed jahmite jahmite ash'aris jahmites jahmiyyah jahmiyyah mu'tazilah jawhar jawharah jawharat ut-tawhid jihah jism jismiyyah kalaam kalaam nafsee kalaam nafsi kalam atomism kalam nafsi karraamiyyah kawthari khabar ul-waahid kullaabi ash'aris kullaabiyyah lafdhiyyah later ash'aris liquor marifah metaphors metaphysics muhammad abduh muhammad sa'eed ramadan al-buti.al-buti muhdath mujassimah murakkab mushabbihah mutafalsifah mutakallimoon mu'tazilah nadhr names naruiji naseehah dhahabiyyah neo-hanbalis nihaayat ul-iqdaam nuh ha mim keller nuh keller nuzool personal development philadelphian ash'aris philadelphian jahmite ash'aris philadelphian jahmites philosophers pseudo-hanbalis qadi abdul-jabbar quraan quran qu'ran qur'an qur'an creationists ridhaa sabeans salafiyyah sawt sayyid qutb self awareness self help shahrastaani shahrastani sifaat sifaat dhaatiyyah sifaat fi'liyyah sifat substance sumaniyyah tahreef tahrif tajseem takyeef tamtheel tamthil tarkeeb tashbeeh ta'teel ta'weel the clinic the quran the throne theologians this i throne top tips uluww undercover ash'aris voice wahhabi wahhabis yahyah bin ammaar

Archives
March 2010
February 2010
January 2010
December 2009
November 2009
October 2009
September 2009
August 2009
July 2009
June 2009


© Asharis.Com. All rights reserved.